Humanitarian Work in Search of a Future

© UN News – Children in Gaza wait to fill their empty saucepans with food

Humanitarian crises are caused by wars, disasters, and epidemics, most often in poor countries. The response to these crises relies first on local community solidarity, followed by assistance from international humanitarian organizations. These, in turn, depend on the response capabilities of humanitarian actors, public and private funding, access to victims, and cooperation among relief actors on the ground.

The sharp decline in public humanitarian funding, geopolitical fragmentation, and the erosion of international humanitarian law are severely impacting relief efforts for victims.

Thus, one of the immediate effects of the U.S.-Israeli war against Iran is to block all trade in the Strait of Hormuz, with multiple global consequences that notably affect the export of fertilizers essential for agriculture, particularly in the poorest countries. This also carries a high risk of triggering a food crisis in the Middle East! This war is spreading to Lebanon, which already has over one million displaced people, including 350,000 children, more than a thousand deaths, and the risk of southern Lebanon being annexed with no possibility of the population returning, as Israel has declared.

This editorial, like every other article from this edition of Défis Humanitaires, aim at providing analysis, testimonies, examples, tools for readers as well as actors of geopolitics, humanitarian work, their partners and parlementaries, journalists, Think Tanks and Faculties, followers and doners who help making possible the publication of Défis Humanitaires.

 

Factors Driving Global Geopolitical Change.

The Russian invasion of Ukraine, the ouster of President Maduro in Venezuela, Donald Trump’s re-election, the U.S.-Israeli attack on Iran, and other threats are upending international relations, risking the very denial of the rule of law.

The return of empires, the symmetrical assertiveness of nation-states, and the emergence of countries in the “Global South” are major contributors to this ongoing dynamic of fragmentation, conflict, and recomposition.

In this context, the president of the world’s leading power, Donald Trump, has as his sole agenda “America Trump First,” which blends both isolationism and interventionism in all global affairs based on the “deal” of power dynamics and interests.

Meeting between heads of states and governements in London to support Volodymyr Zelenky after his altercation with Donald Trump on February 28 at the White House. © European Union, 2025

This aggression will have the opposite effect of radicalizing all parties and situations, as we can see from the increase in defense budgets! Does this make the world any safer, and doesn’t this constant escalation inevitably lead to war in all its forms?

And this does nothing to address, beyond the legitimate interests of each country, the challenges facing all of humanity—challenges that are all sources of collective danger: climate change, melting glaciers, pollution, loss of biodiversity, the drinking water crisis, epidemics, demographics, the criminal economy, the potential proliferation of military nuclear weapons, and so on.

In this new context, the weakening of the UN and of multilateralism equally diminishes the institutions capable of regulation through negotiation.

And yet, we must effectively coordinate the global trade necessary for 8 billion people—who will number 10 billion in 25 years, with Africa’s population set to double! Where are the plans to anticipate this demographic shock? What will be the consequences of our lack of preparation?

 

Strengths, Weaknesses, and Prospects for the Humanitarian Sector.

In a new context where we are witnessing the erosion of international law and where the humanitarian sector is likely to lose half of its public funding, it is useful to take stock of the situation to identify its strengths—so as to optimize them—and its weaknesses—so as to address them—and to explore new avenues and methods yet to be devised.

Without claiming to be exhaustive, these strengths are first and foremost those of commitment and the motivation to act to save lives. They also include responsiveness and pragmatism, as well as professional experience and expertise. There are donor support networks and the coordination of organizations with donors as well as on the ground. Above all, we must not forget the proximity to local populations, public opinion, the media, and government authorities—both in the countries that provide aid and in the countries where it is implemented for populations at risk.

On the downside, we note a lack of strategic foresight, though this is offset, it is true, by a strong capacity for adaptation. We should also highlight the weakness of communication, which is primarily directed at its own staff and which, despite donor support, struggles to break out of its silo and gain broader influence. With a few rare exceptions, NGOs’ business models are either fragile or dependent, lacking significant capacity for investment and renewal.

The mixed Solidarités International-Véolia team around an Aquaforce 2000 in Ukraine. Photo : Veolia Foundation

This brief overview lays the groundwork for a number of initiatives aimed at strengthening our organization while adapting—and even transforming. With this in mind, let us highlight a few potential avenues for progress.

  • Forge new alliances with individual donors, institutional donors, businesses and foundations, the media, research centers, and among humanitarian organizations themselves.
  • Revamp communication by documenting the human consequences of crises with concrete and compelling examples.
  • Better measure the impact of the actions implemented and demonstrate to the public how the resources mobilized improve the lives of populations at risk and save lives, while establishing sustainable responses to essential needs.
  • Show how innovation and pooling of resources enable us to be closer to the people, act more quickly, be more effective, and optimize resources and every euro.
  • At a more strategic level, demonstrate how human security is a prerequisite for international security, as well as why and how national solidarity is compatible with international solidarity.
  • Share, illustrate, and promote the humanitarian principles of humanity, neutrality, impartiality, and independence as the foundation of all action, while avoiding the risks of politicization and division that would weaken us.

Défis Humanitaires doesn’t have all the answers, but our journal explores avenues, solutions, and options both within and outside the “toolbox.” Please feel free to send us your comments and suggestions at: contact@defishumanitaires.com

Défis Humanitaires’ Commitment to You.

Défis Humanitaires is a nonprofit organization established under the French law of 1901 that publishes an independent, free online journal. The costs of this publication are covered by the volunteer work of its expert committee members and numerous contributors (complete list of contributors), as well as by humanitarian and geopolitical networks and by donors who make each new issue possible.

If we were to think in terms of a “business model,” there would be nothing. What makes the difference for Défis Humanitaires are the convictions, the commitment, the experience gained, the friends, donors, and authors without whom this would not exist. And now we are also witnessing the emergence of a new geopolitical era where confrontation is taking hold and war looms, at the very moment when public humanitarian and development funding is collapsing while needs are growing.

This Issue 111 is emblematic of our journal. You will discover a fascinating interview with Maurice Gourdault-Montagne, a seasoned diplomat, who explains the past to us and sheds light on the present and the future. We are very excited to publish testimonials from NGOs such as Électriciens Sans Frontières (ESF), with its president Hervé Gouyet, who presents the results of four years of engagement in Ukraine.

© Électriciens Sans Frontières – Électriciens Sans Frontières in Ukraine

Similarly, we hear from the Solinfo association, which has been active in Bangladesh for 22 years, with a field report that takes us along with Thierry Liebaut, its secretary general, who has just returned from there. In the field of innovation, following last month’s presentation of the remarkable tool, the Solis bot, Antoine Vaccaro of Force For Good offers us a remarkable analysis of philanthropy in times of chaos. Regarding global access to drinking water and the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs 2015–2030), Gérard Payen, vice president of the French Water Partnership, provides an overview of the current situation and strategic challenges of the upcoming UN World Water Summit, which will take place in December 2026 in Abu Dhabi.

 

A New Défis Humanitaires.

In the face of ongoing geopolitical and humanitarian upheavals, our magazine must adapt, evolve, and change to better fulfill its mission and meet readers’ expectations.

This process concerns both content and form. How can we adapt our editorial line to the new geopolitical context? How can we interpret current events to anticipate the world to come? How can we reposition the humanitarian sector, which has been hit hard by the drastic decline in public funding? How can we mobilize new partners and allies? How can we adapt, change, and reinvent ourselves?

How can we adapt our layout and offer new features to our readers? What direction should we take in terms of graphic identity to better express a renewed editorial line?

Please feel free to share your thoughts on these questions with us. It’s very simple—just write to us at contact@defishumanitaires.com

However, while volunteer work is essential to achieving this, it is not enough on its own. We urgently need your support to cover the costs of this new layout and to expand our editorial team so that we can fully develop our content, including articles, testimonials, interviews, and visual materials.

I am therefore appealing to the generosity of our readers—who are our closest and most loyal supporters—by inviting you to make a donation at (faireundon), for which you will receive a tax receipt entitling you to a tax deduction of 66% of the amount donated.

Thank you very much for your support of Défis Humanitaires, a unique monthly magazine that hopes to bring this project to fruition thanks to you. Thank you.

Alain Boinet.

President of Défis Humanitaires.


Alain Boinet is the president of the association Défis Humanitaires which publishes the online review www.defishumanitaires.com. He is the founder of the humanitarian association Solidarités International of which he was director general for 35 years. Moreover, he is a member of the Humanitarian Consultation Group with the Crisis and Support Center of the Ministry for Europe and Foreign Affairs, member of the Board of Directors of Solidarités International, of the French Water Partnership (PFE), of the Véolia Foundation, of the Think Tank (re)sources. He continues to go to the field (north-east Syria, Haut-Karabagh/Artsakh and Armenia) and to testify in the media.


Discover the other articles of this edition :

Gaza, humanitarian aid obstructed – Exclusive interview with Xavier Lauth, Director of Operations at Solidarités International

Bombing in Gaza © UNRWA Ashraf Amra

Alain Boinet: Xavier, you were recently in Gaza, what humanitarian situation did you witness on the ground?

Xavier Lauth: I was in Gaza at the beginning of July 2025, I found a humanitarian situation absolutely exceptional in its scale, a terrible situation, difficult to put into words and figures for a humanitarian. A shocking situation, hardly comparable. People have been displaced not once but sometimes three, four or five times since 2023. These women and men live with the constant fear of being killed in a bombing, they have not been able to offer their children access to a single safe place for two years. Two years of fear that generates a palpable psychological distress.

An exceptional humanitarian situation also due to the famine and the number of people who are hungry. Exceptional also because the territory left to the Palestinians (territory outside the evacuation order zones) is so narrow that the concentration there is immense and people have a feeling of entrapment. Exceptional also because of the number of civilian deaths, including the sad record of humanitarians killed and the level of destruction. Exceptional due to the famine.

Un enfant de sept ans souffrant de malnutrition aiguë sévère et de déshydratation dans le sud de la bande de Gaza en avril.
A seven-year-old child suffering from severe acute malnutrition and dehydration in the south of the Gaza Strip in April. © WHO – A seven-year-old child suffering from severe acute malnutrition and dehydration in the south of the Gaza Strip, April 2025

Alain Boinet: How do people live in Gaza when access to relief is extremely limited?

Xavier Lauth: People do not live in Gaza but survive there. There are almost no schools left for children, no jobs for adults, so people spend their day looking for food and water, seeking medical care, and trying to stay alive. Foodstuffs and all the objects and goods necessary for daily life are rare in Gaza. The drastic entry restrictions imposed by the Israeli army deprive the population of these goods and also prevent finding spare parts to repair or maintain basic services. The Gazans cope by reusing everything possible but the dignity they show cannot diminish the indignity of this situation. Some no longer even have the strength to get up, I met several men, women and elderly people in various places across the Strip, unable to stand because they no longer eat and leave the little food to their children.

Alain Boinet: The work of the “Gaza Humanitarian Foundation (GHF)” is highly controversial, what do humanitarians on the ground think?

Xavier Lauth: Humanitarians in their vast majority consider that the work done by the GHF does not respect the principles that form the basis of our values nor the modus operandi that govern and guide us. The food distribution operations create uncontrolled gatherings of people in a militarized zone. These sites are protected by armed men who shoot at the population as soon as they believe there is a disruption, which inevitably happens, when it is not the crowd movements themselves that cause deaths. I met many people and always heard the same message from the Palestinians: we know it’s dangerous, that it’s not humanitarian aid, but some of us take the risk to go because our families have nothing left to eat. Unfortunately, there are also deaths during looting of humanitarian convoys, but it must be remembered that Israel bears the greatest responsibility, due to the limited quantities allowed in, the control of the truck routes, and the disappearance of civil order caused by the conflict.

©Solidarités International – Water distribution by Solidarités International

©Solidarités International – Water distribution by Solidarités International

Alain Boinet: What exactly is Solidarités International doing in Gaza, with what team and what means of action?

Xavier Lauth: Solidarités International supports and operates desalination stations (owned, with a partner and with private suppliers) which produce drinking water. SI then organizes the distribution of this drinking water by truck throughout the Gaza Strip (in accessible areas). Tens of thousands of liters of water are thus distributed every day in tent sites or destroyed neighborhoods. In addition to this work on drinking water, teams draw and distribute domestic water from various private wells so that people can use it for other purposes. Another part of the intervention also involves securing full latrines and organizing hygiene awareness sessions with the community to establish barriers to the transmission of waterborne diseases. Finally, our teams were starting small agriculture activities on very limited spaces but with the offensive on Gaza City and the renewed displacement of hundreds of thousands of people, there is no more space. Solidarités International has also distributed hygiene items when available, but it is no longer possible to procure any.

To summarize, we make do with what is available on the ground, we do a lot in terms of water supply and for the rest we adapt, we are far from our standards, there is no safe place for our teams but we continue to deliver aid and that’s what matters.

Alain Boinet: On August 22, the UN declared a famine in Gaza based on a report from the Integrated Food Security Phase Classification (IPC), what reality did you observe on the ground and what can be done?

Xavier Lauth: I don’t have any statistical data to add, the IPC work is rigorous. On my level, I can only testify. Testify to visible hunger. People too thin lying down and without strength, women crying because they cannot feed their babies, elderly people collapsing from the shame of admitting they are hungry. It is a very harsh situation, especially since the food is only a few kilometers away…

©Solidarités International – Water distribution by Solidarités International

Alain Boinet: What are the consequences of the ongoing Israeli offensive on the city of Gaza and what more can humanitarian organizations do to help the population?

Xavier Lauth: The consequences are terrible because Gaza City was home to a large part of the population who now find themselves on the roads again, having to find new makeshift shelters further south. Having to move again as they did in 2024 is unbearable. The available space is so limited that it is not possible to deploy minimal humanitarian services. Many hospitals are in Gaza City and will no longer be accessible. Humanitarian organizations will adapt again: new locations for water supply points, new sources of supply, support for people’s resettlement… but without materials, with our own teams forced to evacuate… the humanitarian response is not up to the level of the situation.

Alain Boinet: What specifically characterizes for you the situation and humanitarian action in Gaza compared to emergencies like those in Sudan, Haiti, Ukraine, Yemen, or elsewhere?

Xavier Lauth: I have described above some of the elements that make this situation exceptional but as for humanitarian action, it is surely its level of obstruction that is most specific. The obstacles are numerous in all the crises you mention and humanitarians are very exposed but collectively we generally manage to overcome them or mitigate the consequences. In Gaza, funding levels are overall good for humanitarian actors who therefore have financial means but they cannot deliver aid at scale due to the obstructions and blockades. Such a level does not seem to have ever been reached before.

Alain Boinet: How would you like to conclude?

Xavier Lauth: This war will mark, beyond any political consideration, a turning point in the history of humanitarian work. We must continue, try everything to bring everything we can to Palestinians in distress, it is a moral duty. But this effort will remain derisory as long as the fighting does not stop.


Xavier Lauth:

 

Xavier Lauth has been Director of Operations at Solidarités International (SI) since June 2023. He has worked in the humanitarian sector since 2010. After holding several field positions, he was head of emergency responses at SI for four years and director of operations at SOS Méditerranée for 18 months before rejoining SI.

 

 

 


To learn more about the situation in Gaza and humanitarian work on the ground: